Choice Crusader

3 Best Eyeliner Colors to Make Your Brown Eyes Pop

Heads up: We are community-supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Think finding the perfect eyeliner shade for your brown eyes is tough? No worries. Picking the right color can really up your eye game. Picture your brown eyes popping and sparkling with just a quick flick of eyeliner.

But what colors will get you that wow effect? Let's dive into three eyeliner shades that are pretty much made to make your brown eyes stand out in the best way possible.

NYX Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil, Smokin Topaz – Brown

rich brown eye pencil

For those seeking a versatile and long-lasting eyeliner option that enhances the natural beauty of brown eyes, the NYX Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil in Smokin Topaz is a top choice. The retractable pencil offers intense pigment and a creamy formula that ensures long-lasting wear without the need for sharpening. With its twist-up design, this eyeliner is convenient and easy to use, making it a go-to option for various eye makeup looks.

The Smokin Topaz shade complements brown eyes beautifully, providing a smudge-proof and smooth application that's highly pigmented for a bold color payoff. Waterproof and durable, this eyeliner isn't only affordable but also a high-quality product that receives positive user reviews for its ease of application and vibrant color.

Best For: Those with brown eyes looking for a long-lasting and versatile eyeliner option.


  • Intense pigment and creamy formula for vibrant color payoff.
  • Convenient mechanical design for easy application.
  • Waterproof and durable for all-day wear.


  • Limited color range compared to other brands.

wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil, Simma Brown Now!, 0.04 Ounce

waterproof brown kohl liner

When choosing the best eyeliner colors for brown eyes, consider the wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Liner Pencil in Simma Brown Now! for its long-lasting formula and versatile application. This eyeliner features a new improved formula that offers 12-hour wear, ensuring your eye makeup stays intact throughout the day. The rich, hyper-pigmented color of Simma Brown adds depth and intensity to your eyes with just one swipe. Its smooth and creamy application makes it easy to create various looks without worrying about smudging. Moreover, the affordable price point makes it a budget-friendly option without compromising on quality. With the added convenience of a sharpener on the cap, this liner pencil is a must-have for achieving stunning eye looks effortlessly.

Best For: Those looking for a long-lasting and versatile eyeliner option at an affordable price point.


  • Rich, hyper-pigmented color for intense eye looks
  • Smooth and creamy application for easy use
  • Comes with a sharpener on the cap for added convenience


  • May not be as smudge-proof as some higher-end options

True Color Glimmersticks Eye Liner Cosmic Brown

precise eye makeup essential

To enhance the natural beauty of your brown eyes, consider the True Color Glimmersticks Eye Liner in Cosmic Brown for a long-lasting, smooth application that complements hazel eyes beautifully. This Avon True Color Glimmersticks Eyeliner Pencil is a twist-up retractable pencil that glides on smoothly without smudging, ensuring a long wear throughout the day.

Customers rave about its easy application, with one user mentioning it as their go-to eyeliner for over 20 years. While some find the pigment to be darker than expected, making it ideal for tightlining, others appreciate its lasting power and intense color payoff.

With positive reviews highlighting its affordability, longevity, and rich color, this eyeliner is a great choice for defining and accentuating your brown eyes.

Best For: Those with hazel eyes looking for a long-lasting, smooth eye liner that complements their eye color.


  • Smooth, glide-on color for easy application
  • Long wear ensures lasting power throughout the day
  • Intense color payoff for defining and accentuating the eyes


  • Some users may find the pigment to be darker than expected

Factors to Consider When Choosing Eyeliner Color for Brown Eyes

When choosing eyeliner colors for your brown eyes, consider shades that complement your natural eye color.

Explore options that enhance your eye features and make your brown eyes pop.

With a versatile selection of shades, you can find the perfect eyeliner to accentuate your beautiful brown eyes.

Color Complements Brown

Enhancing the warmth and depth of your brown eyes, consider how earthy tones like bronze, copper, and gold can complement them beautifully. These colors bring out the richness of brown eyes without overpowering them, creating a subtle yet striking look.

Additionally, purple shades such as plum, eggplant, or violet can create a captivating contrast with brown eyes, making them pop. For a unique touch, try teal or turquoise eyeliners to bring out any green or hazel flecks in your brown eyes.

Warm neutrals like terracotta, warm browns, and amber are also great choices to enhance the depth of your eyes. Lastly, metallic shades like bronze, copper, or rose gold add a touch of glamour and brightness to make your brown eyes shine.

Eye-Enhancing Options

Considering the variety of eyeliner colors that can enhance the warmth and depth of your brown eyes, it's essential to understand the key factors that play a role in choosing the perfect shade.

Earthy tones like bronze, copper, and brown add depth, while shades of purple, plum, and burgundy complement brown eyes. Gold and champagne hues create a striking contrast, making your eyes appear brighter.

For a bold look, teal and turquoise eyeliners add a vibrant pop of color. If you prefer a subtle enhancement, neutral shades like taupe and mauve provide a sophisticated touch without overpowering your brown eyes.

Versatile Shade Selection

To select the most flattering eyeliner color for your brown eyes, consider the versatility of shades like deep purples, rich browns, and metallic bronzes. These colors can enhance the warmth and depth of your brown eyes, making them stand out beautifully.

Earthy tones such as olive greens, warm taupes, and coppery hues can also complement your brown eyes, offering a natural and effortless look. If you're feeling bold, try navy blues, emerald greens, or deep plums to add a touch of drama and make your eyes pop.

For a more subtle enhancement, opt for neutral shades like soft grays, deep blues, and dark chocolates. Experimenting with different eyeliner colors will help you discover the perfect shade that suits both your eye color and personal style.

Enhancing Eye Features

When selecting the ideal eyeliner color for your brown eyes, remember to factor in the natural warmth and depth of your eye color. Enhancing your eye features can be achieved by choosing warm tones like bronze, copper, and gold, which complement the natural warmth of brown eyes.

For a striking contrast, deep shades such as plum, navy, and charcoal can make your brown eyes pop. Earthy tones like olive green, terracotta, and chocolate brown beautifully complement brown eyes, enhancing their depth.

If you aim to add a luminous effect, metallic shades including bronze, copper, and rose gold are excellent choices. For a more vibrant and dramatic look, experimenting with jewel tones like emerald, sapphire, and amethyst can bring out the best in your brown eyes.

Brown Eyes Pop

Enhance the allure of your brown eyes by selecting eyeliner colors that accentuate their natural warmth and depth, making them truly pop. Opt for warm tones like bronze, copper, and gold to highlight the richness of your brown eyes.

Deep plum, olive green, and navy blue shades can also enhance the depth and intensity of brown eyes. For added dimension and a touch of shimmer, consider metallic shades such as bronze and copper.

To make your brown eyes stand out, try contrasting colors like teal or violet. For a more subtle look, neutral shades like rich browns and soft taupes can complement your brown eyes while still adding a touch of definition.

Complementing Brown Eyes

How can you determine the best eyeliner color to complement your brown eyes?

When choosing eyeliner colors for brown eyes, consider shades like rich plums, deep greens, and metallic bronzes to enhance their warmth and depth. Earthy tones such as warm browns, copper, and gold can also accentuate brown eyes, creating a harmonious look.

For a striking contrast, opt for contrasting shades like navy blue, charcoal grey, or black to make your brown eyes pop. If you prefer a more subtle look, soft neutrals like taupe, soft pink, and champagne can offer a natural and understated appearance for everyday wear.

Experiment with different colors to find which ones enhance the unique undertones and flecks in your brown eyes.

Flattering Eyeliner Choices

Consider your eye color and undertones when selecting the perfect eyeliner shade to enhance the beauty of your brown eyes. Earthy tones like bronze, copper, and brown are excellent choices as they complement brown eyes beautifully.

If you want a more striking look, opt for dark shades such as navy, charcoal, or black to create a bold contrast. Warm hues like gold, olive, and plum can enhance the warmth in your brown eyes, while metallic shades like bronze and gold add a touch of glamour.

For a pop of color, experiment with jewel tones like emerald, sapphire, and amethyst. By choosing eyeliner colors that suit your eye color and undertones, you can make your brown eyes stand out and sparkle.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can These Eyeliners Be Easily Smudged for a Smokey Eye Look?

Yes, these eyeliners can be easily smudged for a smokey eye look. You'll find that they blend effortlessly, creating a sultry and dramatic effect. Experiment with different techniques to achieve the perfect smoky eye.

Are These Eyeliners Suitable for Sensitive Eyes?

If you have sensitive eyes, these eyeliners are gentle and suitable for you. They won't irritate your eyes and are safe to use. Enjoy wearing them without any discomfort or worries about sensitivity issues.

How Long Do These Eyeliners Typically Last Throughout the Day?

These eyeliners typically last 8-12 hours throughout the day, depending on factors like skin type and activity level. For instance, if you have oily skin, consider using a primer to help extend wear time.

Can These Eyeliners Be Used on the Waterline?

Yes, these eyeliners can be used on the waterline. They provide long-lasting wear and vibrant color payoff. You'll love how they define your eyes and make your brown eyes pop with just a simple application.

Are These Eyeliners Waterproof or Water-Resistant?

If you're wondering if the eyeliners are waterproof or water-resistant, you'll be pleased to know that they are water-resistant. This means they can withstand some moisture without smudging, making them ideal for long-lasting wear.