Choice Crusader

3 Best Eyeliners for Oily Lids That Will Stay Put All Day

Heads up: We are community-supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Got oily lids and tired of your eyeliner smudging or disappearing by lunchtime? You're in luck! We've got the scoop on three eyeliners that are perfect for battling that pesky oil and keeping your eye makeup looking sharp all day long.

Whether you're all about that liquid liner life or you prefer a classic pencil, these picks have got you covered. Let's dive into which eyeliners are winning the fight against oily lids and will keep your look on point from breakfast to bedtime.

stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

precision pigment waterproof longevity

For those with oily lids seeking a long-lasting and smudge-proof eyeliner, look no further than the Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner. This eyeliner comes highly recommended for its ability to withstand humidity, swimming, and workouts, making it perfect for tropical climates.

The precise felt tip applicator allows you to create various looks, from thin lines to dramatic wings, with ease. Users praise the intense black color, smooth application, and long-lasting wear of this eyeliner. While some mention it may not be entirely smudge-proof for watery eyes or extended wear on the corners, its easy removal with makeup remover pads is noted.

When prepping the eye area with toner, eye cream, foundation, and matte powder, you ensure a smooth surface for precise application.

Best For: Those with oily lids looking for a long-lasting and smudge-proof eyeliner.


  • Intense black color
  • Smooth application
  • Long-lasting wear


  • May not be entirely smudge-proof for watery eyes or extended wear on the corners

Revlon Pencil Eyeliner, ColorStay Eye Makeup (201 Black)

revlon colorstay eye pencil

With its long-wearing and waterproof formula, the Revlon Pencil Eyeliner in ColorStay Eye Makeup (201 Black) is ideal for those with oily lids seeking a smudge-proof and lasting eyeliner solution. This eyeliner offers up to 24 hours of wear with a smooth and creamy application. The intense shade of black is versatile for creating different eyeliner looks, and the built-in sharpener ensures precise lines. Users appreciate its smudge-proof qualities, making it suitable for sensitive eyes. While some users experienced issues with breakage, many find it easy to apply with good color payoff. Overall, the Revlon Pencil Eyeliner is praised for its staying power throughout the day, affordability, and performance, making it a popular choice for those looking for a reliable eyeliner option.

Best For: Those with oily lids seeking a long-wearing, smudge-proof eyeliner solution.


  • Long-wearing and waterproof formula lasting up to 24 hours.
  • Smooth and creamy application for easy use.
  • Intense shade for versatile eyeliner looks.


  • Some users experienced breakage issues with the built-in sharpener.

NYX Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner – Black

waterproof black liquid liner

If you struggle with oily lids, the NYX Epic Ink Liner in black offers a smudge-proof solution for long-lasting eyeliner looks. This waterproof matte liquid eyeliner features a vegan formula and an ultra-precise tip that allows for flexible and easy application. Customers praise its ease of use and long-lasting wear, making it ideal for various eye makeup looks.

While some users noted that it may require touch-ups for extended wear, many appreciate its forgiving application and minimal effort required. The fine marker-like tip ensures precise and sharp lines, enhancing the overall makeup look. Despite not being completely waterproof or smudge-proof for some users, the NYX Epic Ink Liner is recommended for its price, quality, and reliable performance on oily lids.

Best For: Those with oily lids looking for a smudge-proof and long-lasting eyeliner solution.


  • Waterproof formula
  • Ultra-precise tip for easy application
  • Long-lasting wear


  • May require touch-ups for extended wear

Factors to Consider When Choosing Eyeliner for Oily Lids

When choosing eyeliner for oily lids, consider the type of formula that works best for oily skin. Opt for matte finishes and waterproof options to combat excess oil. This will ensure your eyeliner stays put all day.

Also, pay attention to the longevity of the product and whether it's smudge-proof. These factors will help you find the perfect eyeliner that stays vibrant and precise on your oily lids.

Oily Lid Eyeliner Types

For choosing the best eyeliner for oily lids, consider various types like gel, liquid pen, pencil, and cream that offer long wear and smudge-proof formulas.

Gel eyeliners are a popular choice for oily lids due to their long-lasting and smudge-proof formula.

Liquid pen eyeliners with a waterproof and oil-resistant formula can withstand oily lids without smudging.

Pencil eyeliners with a creamy and waterproof texture are suitable for oily lids, providing easy application and long wear.

Cream eyeliners offer a blendable and long-lasting option for oily lids, creating precise lines with a matte finish.

Oily lid-specific eyeliners often contain ingredients like clay or silicone to absorb excess oil and prevent smudging.

Longevity on Oily Skin

To ensure your eyeliner lasts all day on oily skin, prioritize selecting formulas that are waterproof or water-resistant. These formulations are designed to withstand the excess oils on your lids, preventing smudging and ensuring long-lasting wear.

Gel or liquid eyeliners are generally more effective on oily skin compared to pencil eyeliners due to their staying power. When choosing an eyeliner for oily lids, consider options with smudge-proof and transfer-resistant properties to avoid any makeup mishaps throughout the day.

Additionally, look for products that specifically mention suitability for oily skin or long-lasting wear to ensure your eyeliner can handle the challenges posed by oily skin and stay put for hours without fading.

Smudge-Proof Formulations

For oily lids, selecting eyeliners with smudge-proof formulations is crucial to maintain a lasting and immaculate eye look throughout the day. To combat the challenges of oily skin, opt for eyeliners that offer long-lasting and waterproof properties.

Gel and liquid eyeliners with quick-drying formulas are ideal choices as they prevent smudging and smearing on oily lids. Look for products with oil-absorbing ingredients like kaolin clay or silica to help control excess oil and maintain a clean finish.

It's also beneficial to choose eyeliners specifically labeled as suitable for oily skin or lids for better longevity and performance. By prioritizing smudge-proof formulations, you can ensure your eyeliner stays put and looks flawless all day long.

Matte Finish Preference

When selecting an eyeliner for oily lids, consider the preference for a matte finish due to its oil-absorbing properties and long-lasting formula.

Matte finish eyeliners are ideal for oily lids as they help absorb excess oil and reduce shine throughout the day. This type of eyeliner provides a smooth, non-reflective look that helps prevent smudging and creasing on oily eyelids.

Matte eyeliners also tend to have a longer-lasting formula on oily skin compared to shiny or glossy finishes. By choosing a matte eyeliner, you can maintain a clean and polished eye makeup look on oily lids without the need for frequent touch-ups.

Additionally, the matte texture of the eyeliner can create a more defined and precise line on oily lids, enhancing the overall eye makeup appearance.

Waterproof Eyeliner Options

Consider the benefits of waterproof eyeliners when choosing the best option for your oily lids to ensure long-lasting wear and resistance to smudging. Waterproof eyeliners are designed to resist smudging and fading, making them ideal for oily lids. Look for products labeled as waterproof, sweat-proof, or smudge-proof to guarantee longevity on oily eyelids.

These eyeliners typically contain ingredients that repel moisture and oils, catering to oily skin types. Some waterproof formulas have quick-drying properties that help prevent transfer or smudging on oily lids. When selecting a waterproof eyeliner for oily lids, opt for long-lasting formulas with intense pigmentation and a matte finish to keep your eye look intact all day.

Application Tips for Oiliness

To combat oiliness on your lids, opt for gel or liquid eyeliners with waterproof or smudge-proof formulas for long-lasting wear.

Use an oil-free primer designed for eyelids to create a smooth base for eyeliner application.

Set your eyeliner with a matching eyeshadow to absorb excess oil and prolong its wear.

Avoid creamy or kohl eyeliners that can smudge easily on oily lids.

Consider applying a translucent setting powder on the eyelids before eyeliner to control oil and enhance longevity.

Price Range Considerations

As you explore eyeliners for oily lids, evaluating price ranges becomes crucial to finding a suitable option that balances quality and affordability. High-end brands often offer longer-lasting formulas but come with a higher cost, while drugstore options can provide decent performance at a more budget-friendly price point.

Mid-range eyeliners offer a balance between quality and cost, catering to oily lids without exceeding your budget. Some specialized eyeliners formulated for oily lids may have a higher price due to their smudge and fade-resistant properties.

Comparing the price per ounce of different eyeliners can help you determine the most cost-effective choice for managing oily lids effectively. Consider your preferences and budget when selecting the best eyeliner for your oily lids.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Oily Eyelids Cause Eyeliner to Smudge or Fade Throughout the Day?

When oily eyelids strike, your eyeliner becomes a fugitive, smudging and fading with each passing hour. Fight back with the right products, locking that liner in place all day long. Defend your look!

Are There Any Specific Ingredients or Formulas to Look for in Eyeliners That Are Designed for Oily Lids?

When choosing eyeliners for oily lids, opt for water-resistant or waterproof formulas. Look for gel or liquid liners with long-lasting wear. These features help prevent smudging and fading throughout the day, keeping your eye makeup fresh.

How Can I Prevent My Eyeliner From Transferring Onto My Eyelid Crease?

To prevent eyeliner transfer onto your lid crease, start by applying an eyeshadow base or primer to create a smooth surface. Set your eyeliner with a matching eyeshadow to lock it in place all day.

Will Using a Primer or Setting Spray Help My Eyeliner Stay in Place on Oily Lids?

Using a primer or setting spray can help your eyeliner stay in place on oily lids. They create a base that grips the eyeliner, preventing it from smudging or transferring onto your eyelid crease throughout the day.

Are There Any Tips or Tricks for Applying Eyeliner to Oily Lids to Ensure Long-Lasting Wear?

To ensure long-lasting wear on your oily lids, consider setting your eyeliner with a matching eyeshadow, using a waterproof formula, and applying thin layers. These steps can help prevent smudging and keep your eyeliner in place all day.