Choice Crusader

3 Best Eyeliners for Tightlining That Will Transform Your Eye Makeup Game

Heads up: We are community-supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Looking for that secret sauce to amp up your eye makeup? Tightlining is where it's at, but you need the right eyeliner to really make it pop. Think of it like finding a hidden gem that suddenly makes everything click.

You know, adding that subtle but oh-so-important definition to your lash line that just makes your eyes stand out. So, which eyeliners are the real MVPs for tightlining? Stick around, because I'm about to spill the beans on three game-changers that could totally transform how you do your eyes.

Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner, Black

waterproof gel pencil eyeliner

For those seeking a long-lasting and user-friendly option for tightlining, the Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner in Black is an excellent choice. This eyeliner offers high-intensity color that instantly enhances your eyes. Its ultra-smooth and creamy formula glides on effortlessly, providing a smudge-proof, sweat-proof, heat-proof, and waterproof finish.

Dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested, this eyeliner is safe even for sensitive eyes. Lasting all day without running, it's perfect for waterline application, especially for small eyes and fair skin tones. The creamy texture allows for a light application that brightens your eyes with a subtle sparkling black hue. Experience easy application without tugging, irritation, or difficulty in removal, making your tightlining routine a breeze.

Best For: Those looking for a long-lasting and user-friendly eyeliner option that's smudge-proof and safe for sensitive eyes.


  • High-intensity color for instant impact.
  • Ultra smooth & creamy formula for easy application.
  • Water, sweat, heat, and smudge-proof for all-day wear.


  • Doesn't last as long as expected.

Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer Eyeliner, Blackest Black, 0.01oz

waterproof black eyeliner rimmel

With its highly pigmented formula and built-in smudger, the Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer Eyeliner in Blackest Black is an ideal choice for those seeking a long-lasting and intense eyeliner for tightlining. This waterproof eyeliner offers a deep black color that stays put for up to 10 hours, ensuring your eye makeup remains flawless throughout the day. Customers praise its easy application, smudge-proof finish, and value for money. The inclusion of a sharpener further enhances its convenience and versatility. Users enjoy its smooth application, which allows for precise lines or a smoky effect. While some encountered issues with product breakage, the majority laud its quality and longevity, making it a reliable option for defining and accentuating your eyes.

Best For: Those looking for a long-lasting and intense black eyeliner with easy application and smudge-proof finish.


  • Highly pigmented formula for intense color.
  • Waterproof and long-lasting wear up to 10 hours.
  • Built-in smudger and sharpener for added convenience and versatility.


  • Some users may experience issues with product breakage.

NYX Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil, Retractable Eyeliner – Always Onyx

rich black retractable eyeliner

Ideal for those seeking a long-lasting, intense pigment without the hassle of sharpening, the NYX Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil in Always Onyx is a standout choice for tightlining. This retractable eyeliner pen boasts a creamy formula that glides on effortlessly, ensuring a smooth and smudge-proof application.

With no sharpening required, you can simply twist up the pencil to reveal more product, making it convenient for on-the-go touch-ups. The NYX Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil is known for its high color payoff and long-lasting wear without smudging or fading throughout the day.

Additionally, it comes at an affordable price point, offering exceptional quality and value for your makeup collection.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Eyeliner for Tightlining

When choosing an eyeliner for tightlining, consider factors like:

  • Application techniques
  • Eyeliner color selection
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof formulas
  • Longevity and wear
  • Eye sensitivity

These elements play a crucial role in achieving a seamless and long-lasting tightlining effect that enhances your eyes. By evaluating these aspects, you can find the perfect eyeliner that meets your tightlining needs.

Application Techniques

For precise application of eyeliner for tightlining, consider selecting a gel or waterproof pencil liner to prevent smudging or running. Tightlining involves applying eyeliner to the upper waterline to enhance the appearance of fuller lashes. To achieve this, a steady hand and a small, precise brush or pencil tip are essential for accurate application on the waterline.

Tightlining can create the illusion of a thicker, more defined lash line without an obvious makeup look, making eyes appear more awake, enhancing eye shape, and adding subtle definition. By using the right eyeliner and mastering the application technique, you can transform your eye makeup game with beautifully enhanced eyes that look naturally defined and captivating.

Eyeliner Color Selection

To enhance your tightlining technique further, the choice of eyeliner color plays a crucial role in achieving a natural and captivating look. For a subtle and fuller lash appearance, opt for dark, matte shades like black or dark brown.

Steer clear of shimmer or glitter eyeliners, as they can accentuate fine lines and detract from the desired effect. Matching your eyeliner to your mascara can provide a polished, cohesive look.

Experiment with navy or charcoal for a softer appearance, or choose neutral tones like taupe or gray for versatility, especially suitable for daytime or natural makeup styles. Selecting the right eyeliner color can elevate your tightlining game and enhance your overall eye makeup aesthetic.

Waterproof and Smudge-Proof

Consider the benefits of using waterproof and smudge-proof eyeliners when tightlining to ensure long-lasting and defined eye makeup.

Waterproof eyeliner is crucial for tightlining, as it prevents smudging and running, especially in the waterline area. Opt for smudge-proof formulas that stay in place throughout the day without fading or transferring onto the skin.

Look for ingredients like silicone derivatives in waterproof eyeliners, as they create a long-lasting, smudge-proof barrier. Tightlining with a waterproof and smudge-proof eyeliner can enhance the appearance of fuller lashes and make your eyes look more defined.

Select an eyeliner specifically designed for the waterline to ensure it remains in place and doesn't cause irritation or discomfort.

Longevity and Wear

When selecting an eyeliner for tightlining, prioritize longevity and wear to ensure your eye makeup stays flawless throughout the day. Opt for eyeliners labeled as long-wearing or waterproof to resist smudging and fading caused by moisture and oils on the waterline.

Look for ingredients like silicone that create a barrier for enhanced adherence to the skin, increasing the eyeliner's longevity. Gel or gel pencil eyeliners are excellent choices for tightlining due to their superior staying power compared to traditional pencil or liquid liners.

Consider your climate and skin type when selecting a long-wearing eyeliner to ensure it performs optimally under your specific conditions.

Eye Sensitivity Considerations

For those with sensitive eyes, prioritizing gentle formulas is crucial when selecting an eyeliner for tightlining. To prevent irritation, opt for hypoallergenic eyeliners and choose products that have been tested by ophthalmologists to ensure they're safe for sensitive eyes.

Look for fragrance-free options specifically formulated for the delicate skin around the eyes. Avoid eyeliners with harsh chemicals or preservatives that could trigger discomfort or allergic reactions. Before applying the eyeliner to your waterline, test a small amount on your skin to check for any adverse reactions.

Taking these precautions can help you avoid potential issues and keep your eyes comfortable and healthy while tightlining.

Removal Methods

To ensure gentle removal without causing irritation, prioritize eyeliners formulated for tightlining that can be easily removed with makeup remover or micellar water. When choosing an eyeliner for tightlining, it's essential to consider the removal methods to prevent tugging or pulling on the delicate skin around your eyes.

Opt for waterproof or long-lasting formulas that can withstand daily wear but are still simple to remove at the end of the day. If you encounter stubborn eyeliners, consider using oil-based makeup removers for effective cleansing.

Select eyeliners specifically designed for tightlining to ensure efficient removal without causing any irritation or redness. Prioritizing easy removal methods will help maintain the health and appearance of your eye area.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Tightlining With Eyeliner Cause Irritation to Sensitive Eyes?

Tightlining with eyeliner can lead to irritation in sensitive eyes. Around 20% of individuals with sensitive eyes may experience discomfort. Ensure you choose a gentle formula and avoid getting the eyeliner directly on your waterline to minimize irritation.

How Often Should Eyeliner for Tightlining Be Sharpened?

To keep your tightlining precise and safe, sharpen your eyeliner every few uses. This maintains a clean tip, reducing the risk of eye irritation. Regular sharpening ensures smooth application and enhances your eye makeup look.

Is It Necessary to Use a Specific Type of Eyeliner Brush for Tightlining?

When tightlining, using a specific eyeliner brush isn't necessary, but it can enhance precision. A good quality brush with firm bristles helps control product application. Experiment to find what works best for you.

Can Tightlining With Eyeliner Affect Contact Lens Wearers?

If you wear contact lenses, tightlining with eyeliner can potentially lead to eye irritation or transfer of product onto your lenses. Consider using a waterproof or smudge-proof formula to minimize these issues and consult with your eye care professional for advice.

Are There Any Specific Techniques or Tips for Applying Eyeliner for Tightlining on Different Eye Shapes?

For different eye shapes, adjust eyeliner application. Start by tightlining inner lash line for depth. Use a pencil or gel liner for precision. Experiment to find what works best for you! Your eyes will pop!