Choice Crusader

3 Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies Recommended by Pediatricians

Heads up: We are community-supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Hey, did you catch that using pacifiers could actually cut the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) in half? Pretty amazing, right?

When you're hunting for the perfect pacifier for your breastfed munchkin, there are some go-to brands that pediatricians swear by. These are not your average pacifiers—they're specially crafted to support breastfeeding while keeping your baby comfy and calm.

Each one has its own cool features that really make them stand out, making sure both you and your little one have a great experience.

Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier, BPA-Free Binkies (2-Count)

breast like bpa free pacifiers

For breastfed babies seeking a pacifier that mimics the natural latch and feel of breastfeeding, the Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier stands out as an ideal choice. This BPA-free binky features a breast-like design with a symmetrical shape for correct placement in your baby's mouth. The air holes ensure skin breathability, and the included reusable sterilizer pod adds convenience.

Made from super soft silicone, this pacifier has a flexible, skin-like texture inspired by the Closer to Nature® nipple. Its curved shield allows for ventilation and airflow, promoting comfort. Easy to clean and dishwasher safe, this pacifier has received positive feedback for its design and functionality, making it a preferred choice for picky babies and aiding in self-soothing and comfort.

Best For: Breastfed babies looking for a pacifier that closely mimics the natural latch and feel of breastfeeding.


  • Symmetrical design for correct placement
  • Air holes for skin breathability
  • Made from super soft silicone with a flexible, skin-like texture


  • May not suit all babies' preferences

Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers 0-3 Month (2 Pack, Pink)

nanobebe pink pacifier set

Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers 0-3 Month (2 Pack, Pink) offer a soft, ergonomic design ideal for breastfeeding babies, ensuring comfort and healthy oral development. Made from 100% silicone, these pacifiers feature an award-winning, seamless one-piece construction that's BPA and Phthalate-free. Customers appreciate the design similarity to Nanobebe bottles, as well as the soft and gentle silicone material that supports healthy oral development. With positive feedback on comfort and ease of cleaning, these pacifiers are suitable for newborns and premies due to their small nipple size. While some users reported issues with the nipple falling out, the overall consensus leans towards satisfaction with the product's design and functionality.

Best For: Breastfeeding babies looking for a comfortable and orthodontic pacifier option.


  • Ergonomic design suitable for newborns and premies
  • Soft, gentle silicone material supporting healthy oral development
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe


  • Some users experienced issues with the nipple falling out

Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier (4-Count)

lightweight silicone pacifier set

With its ultra-lightweight design and high acceptance rate among babies, the Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier is an excellent choice for parents seeking a comfortable and hygienic pacifier option for their little ones. This BPA-free silicone pacifier is suitable for babies aged 0-6 months, with a symmetrical one-piece design that promotes correct placement in the mouth. The pacifier's skin-like feel, curved shield for comfort, and large airflow holes prevent moisture build-up. Parents appreciate its hygienic properties, as it's easy to clean and dishwasher safe.

With a 97.5% acceptance rate by babies, this pacifier has anti-static properties, stays in place, and is recommended by many satisfied users. The Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier is a top choice for caregivers looking for a reliable and baby-friendly pacifier option.

Best For: Parents looking for a lightweight, easy-to-clean, and highly accepted pacifier option for their babies.


  • Lightweight design
  • High acceptance rate among babies
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe


  • Limited to babies aged 0-6 months

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Pacifier for Breastfed Baby

When choosing a pacifier for your breastfed baby, consider the material for your baby's comfort, the shape and fit for proper latch, and safety and health factors.

Additionally, look into ease of cleaning and maintenance, as well as choosing an age-appropriate design for your little one's stage of development.

Material for Baby

Consider choosing a pacifier made from soft and flexible silicone material for your breastfed baby, ensuring gentle care for their delicate skin and safety from harmful chemicals. Silicone is a popular choice due to its softness and flexibility, making it comfortable for your baby.

Opt for BPA-free silicone to prevent any exposure to harmful substances. Look for one-piece seamless designs to eliminate the risk of small parts detaching. Silicone pacifiers are durable, resistant to wear and tear, and often dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.

Shape and Fit

For your breastfed baby, selecting a pacifier with a symmetrical shape that mimics the natural latch of breastfeeding is crucial for preventing nipple confusion and ensuring correct placement.

Look for a pacifier that offers a flexible and skin-like texture to provide comfort and familiarity for your little one. It's also important to check for air holes in the shield of the pacifier to allow for skin breathability and ventilation, reducing the risk of irritation.

Opt for a pacifier made from BPA-free materials to prioritize your baby's health and safety. Additionally, choose a pacifier that's easy to clean and maintain, preferably dishwasher safe, to ensure hygiene and convenience for both you and your baby.

Safety and Health

Choosing a pacifier that prioritizes your baby's health and safety is essential for breastfeeding parents. Ensure the pacifier is BPA-free and made from safe materials to protect your baby from harmful substances.

Look for symmetrical designs to promote correct placement and prevent nipple confusion, aiding in breastfeeding success. Opt for pacifiers with air holes for breathability, reducing the risk of skin irritation.

Select pacifiers that are easy to clean and sterilize, maintaining proper hygiene standards. Consider choosing pacifiers recommended for breastfed babies to ensure compatibility with your feeding method.

Cleaning and Maintenance

To ensure the cleanliness and hygiene of pacifiers for breastfed babies, prioritize daily washing with warm, soapy water to prevent bacterial growth. Boiling pacifiers for 5 minutes each day can effectively sterilize them for hygiene.

Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive scrubbers to prevent material damage. Regularly check pacifiers for wear, tear, discoloration, or damage, replacing them as needed for safety.

Store pacifiers in a clean, dry container when not in use to maintain cleanliness and prevent contamination. By following these cleaning and maintenance practices, you can ensure that your breastfed baby's pacifier remains safe and hygienic for regular use.

Age-Appropriate Design

When selecting a pacifier for your breastfed baby, prioritize age-appropriate design to ensure a comfortable fit and support healthy oral development. Look for pacifiers specifically designed for newborns to ensure they fit well in your baby's small mouth.

Choosing a symmetrical or orthodontic design can mimic the natural shape of the breast, aiding in proper oral development. Opt for pacifiers made from soft silicone materials for a gentle touch resembling the breast. Ensure the pacifier has air holes or a curved shield to promote airflow and reduce skin irritation.

Additionally, selecting BPA-free pacifiers will guarantee the safety of your breastfed baby and provide peace of mind for you as a parent.

Comfort and Soothing

Consider pacifiers that mimic the natural feel of breastfeeding to provide comfort and soothing for your breastfed baby. Look for pacifiers with a symmetrical design that encourages proper latch and positioning, similar to breastfeeding.

Opt for pacifiers featuring air holes in the shield to enhance skin breathability and reduce the risk of irritation, especially for sensitive babies. Prioritize BPA-free pacifiers for your baby's safety and your peace of mind.

Choose pacifiers that are easy to clean and maintain, as hygiene is crucial for your baby's overall health. By selecting a pacifier that replicates the breastfeeding experience, you can help ensure your baby feels comforted and soothed while using it.

Acceptance and Use

When selecting a pacifier for your breastfed baby, prioritize options that mimic the shape and feel of a mother's nipple for easier acceptance. This similarity can help your baby transition between nursing and pacifier use seamlessly.

Opt for pacifiers with symmetrical designs to ensure proper placement in your baby's mouth, promoting comfort and ease of use. Look for pacifiers with air holes to enhance breathability and reduce moisture buildup, keeping your little one comfortable during extended use.

Choose pacifiers made from safe materials like BPA-free silicone to provide a natural and secure experience for your breastfed baby. Consider pacifiers specifically designed for breastfed babies, as they may feature curved shields for improved ventilation and airflow, catering to your baby's unique needs.

Brand Comparison

To make an informed choice for your breastfed baby's pacifier, compare the features and benefits of popular brands like Tommee Tippee and Nanobebe.

Tommee Tippee pacifiers are designed to feel like natural breastfeeding, aiding in the transition for breastfed infants. They feature a symmetrical one-piece design with a skin-like texture, promoting proper oral development.

On the other hand, Nanobebe pacifiers are praised for their ergonomic shape and seamless silicone construction, particularly suitable for newborns and breastfeeding babies. Nanobebe offers various sizes, including a Stage 2 option, catering to the evolving needs of growing infants.

Both brands prioritize safety, with Tommee Tippee pacifiers being BPA-free and lightweight for extended comfort and Nanobebe pacifiers designed for ease of use and comfort.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Pacifiers Help With Breastfeeding Difficulties, Such as Nipple Confusion or Latch Issues?

Pacifiers can assist with breastfeeding challenges like nipple confusion or latch problems. They offer comfort and sucking practice without affecting breastfeeding. Look for pacifiers recommended by pediatricians for breastfed babies to support nursing success.

How Often Should Pacifiers Be Sterilized for a Breastfed Baby?

You should sterilize pacifiers for your breastfed baby daily. It's key to prevent infections. Think of it like washing your hands before a meal – a simple habit for their health and safety.

Are There Any Specific Techniques for Introducing a Pacifier to a Breastfed Baby?

When introducing a pacifier to your breastfed baby, start by offering it during calm moments. Hold off until breastfeeding is well established, usually around 3-4 weeks. Opt for orthodontic pacifiers and be patient as they adjust.

Can Using a Pacifier Affect a Breastfed Baby's Milk Supply or Feeding Schedule?

Using a pacifier won't necessarily affect your breastfed baby's milk supply or feeding schedule. It's more about how you introduce it. Keep an eye on your baby's cues to ensure they're still nursing enough.

Are There Any Potential Risks or Drawbacks to Using Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies Recommended by Pediatricians?

Using pacifiers for breastfed babies, even those recommended by pediatricians, may pose risks. These include potential nipple confusion, decreased milk supply, and dental issues. It's essential to monitor use and consult with your pediatrician.